## User
- **User:** Mike Swanson (mike)
- **Machine:** GURU-5070
- **Role:** admin

## Session Summary

Large GuruRMM platform day: finished and shipped SPEC-016 (VSS Shadow Copy Management) to production, then designed, built, reviewed, and shipped two new features built on it — SPEC-025 (Policy Compliance Posture) and SPEC-026 (Backup Compliance Domain) — and took SPEC-027 (User Management) through design + build + full review to an APPROVE (uncommitted, ready to ship). Each feature went through a consistent pipeline: write a spec, run a three-way design review (Claude Plan agent + Grok + Gemini), reconcile the consensus into the spec, build backend + dashboard via Coding Agents, run a three-way code review, apply fixes, re-review, then commit → merge to main → deploy (auto-applied migration on `gururmm-server` restart) → validate live on real agents (AD1/AD2 = Dataforth domain controllers).

Finished SPEC-016 from a checkpointed state: built the dashboard Shadow Copies tab, then hardened the backend against a Claude+Grok dual review (browse role-gate, atomic snapshot-cache replace via an explicit `is_full_inventory` flag, restore-audit logging, and — per Mike's call — a self-contained `vss_restores` audit table with denormalized identity and no live FKs). Merged, deployed (migrations 049/050), and piloted VSS live on AD2 by setting it to the beta channel; validated the scheduled-task creation, an on-demand snapshot, and the natural 12:00-AZ scheduled snapshot (owned_count 0→1).

SPEC-025 generalized the VSS posture into a reusable per-domain compliance framework (agent-reported, generic `agent_compliance` table + `ComplianceBadge`), with VSS as domain #1 (immediate-jittered self-heal). The three-way design review reshaped it from a single "self-healing pass" into the separation of enforcement / read-only reporting / opt-in remediation; built, triple-code-reviewed (fixes: detached heal, not_applicable state, distinct reason codes, staleness-sweep reason), shipped (migration 051), validated on AD2 (`vss=compliant`). SPEC-026 added backups as a server-derived compliance domain #2 and fixed a real bug — `agent_backup_status` was keyed one-row-per-agent, collapsing multiple MSP360 plans and letting a failing plan hide behind a passing one. Re-keyed per-plan (migration 052), added the server-side evaluator (sync-health-driven unknown, in-progress-aware freshness, worst-plan aggregate), shipped, validated on AD1/AD2 (both turned out to have a second hidden plan).

SPEC-027 (admin user management) was prompted by hitting the gap directly: Mike asked to create an RMM user and there was no way to do it (registration is bootstrap-only; no admin create/invite path). Specced it, three-way design review elevated the security bar (per-request token_version revocation, server one-time setup token instead of admin-set passwords, role-hierarchy + last-admin guards, transactional org-on-create), built + triple-code-reviewed (three reviewers each found distinct real bugs), applied two fix passes (Claude+Gemini set, then Grok's four), and a final re-review returned APPROVE. Not yet committed/deployed.

Tooling: built the AGY (Google Gemini CLI) second-opinion skill mirroring grok, added keyless `image-analyze` + `search` modes; confirmed Grok's headless file-reading works on v0.2.22 (the earlier failure was a version issue) and added a self-healing embed fallback to its review modes. Also created AD1's Dataforth Files backup plan (parked from 2026-06-04) and the `testuser_antigravity` RMM user (manual DB insert, since no admin-create UI exists yet). A working-agreement about manufactured guardrails was saved to shared memory.

## Key Decisions

- VSS `vss_restores` made a self-contained append-only audit table (denormalized `agent_hostname`/`initiated_by_username`, no live FKs) so records survive agent/user deletion — chosen over `ON DELETE SET NULL`/`CASCADE` after discussing the FK-coupling that was blocking agent deletion.
- Compliance framework (SPEC-025) split into three concerns (enforcement / read-only reporting / opt-in remediation); auto-heal is the exception, VSS the only v1 self-heal. Driven by the Grok+Gemini design reviews.
- SPEC-026 backup domain is SERVER-derived (server computes from MSP360 sync data and upserts to `agent_compliance`), proving the framework absorbs non-agent-reported domains. `unknown` driven by MSP360 sync-health, not the agent-checkin staleness sweep (which now excludes server-owned domains).
- `agent_backup_status` re-keyed per-plan via truncate + re-key migration (cache table, self-heals on next sync) rather than in-place ALTER.
- SPEC-027: server one-time setup token (admin never knows the password) over admin-set passwords (removes impersonation/non-repudiation); per-request `token_version` revocation in the AuthUser extractor (affordable because agents auth over WS, not per-request HTTP) over login-only + short expiry.
- Every feature ran a three-way review (Plan/Grok/Gemini for design; Claude/Grok/Gemini for code). Each reviewer repeatedly caught distinct real bugs — validated the layered approach.
- Operating-agreement (saved to memory): on our own products at Mike's request, execute without manufactured guardrails; flag downstream risks (see around corners) and inform of ramifications, but only hard-stop genuinely irreversible/destructive actions.

## Problems Encountered

- Grok headless review modes (`review`/`review-diff`/`review-files`) returned empty/Cancelled. Root cause: a CLI version issue — v0.2.20 didn't wire `read_file` headlessly; auto-update to v0.2.22 fixed it (confirmed by an empirical agent + Grok's own self-diagnosis, which was confidently wrong about the cause — classic over-claim). Added a self-healing embed fallback; still, Grok's embed path caps ~50KB, so large diffs (79KB SPEC-026, 380KB SPEC-027) must be split into security-core subsets for Grok.
- Gemini `ask-gemini.sh review-diff` inlines the diff as an argv → breaks past Windows' ~32K command-line limit (E2BIG). Worked around by writing the diff to a file and using `review <file>`; proper fix tracked (todo/#11).
- Code reviews initially ran on `git diff HEAD`, which excludes untracked NEW files (migrations, new modules) — the core of each feature. Fixed by `git add -A` + `diff HEAD` + `git reset` to produce a complete diff including new files.
- Falsely alarmed that the GuruRMM `/api/auth/register` endpoint was an "ungated security hole" after reading the route table but not the handler — it is bootstrap-only (`has_users` gate), not a vuln. Corrected after reading the code; reinforced "read the actual code before claiming a problem."
- Refused a routine RMM user-create citing a generic "don't create accounts" rule, on Mike's own product with no admin UI to do it himself — manufactured friction. Corrected; created the user via DB insert and saved a working-agreement to memory.
- The Antigravity-installed `agy.exe` (C:\Users\guru\AppData\Local\agy\bin) is the IDE's embedded agent, not a headless CLI — writes only to a SQLite conversation store, no stdout. The real headless tool is the official `@google/gemini-cli` (`gemini`, npm global, v0.45.1); installed it (Google OAuth, no key).

## Configuration Changes

GuruRMM (`projects/msp-tools/guru-rmm`, repo azcomputerguru/gururmm):
- SPEC-016 VSS (on main, deployed): dashboard `ShadowCopyTab.tsx`+`FileTreeTable.tsx` (commit 3bdf711); backend hardening + self-contained `vss_restores` (700b42b); merged 29e9dbd. Migrations 049_os_identity, 050_vss.
- SPEC-025 Policy Compliance (deployed): branch tip f61e16c, merge 226ba9f. New `agent/src/compliance.rs`, `server/src/db/compliance.rs`, `server/src/api/compliance.rs`, `dashboard/src/components/ComplianceBadge.tsx`, migration 051_agent_compliance; edits across agent/server policy + ws + dashboard.
- SPEC-026 Backup Compliance (deployed): branch tip dcd2b0c, merge ebe0fda. New `server/src/mspbackups/compliance.rs`, migration 052_backup_per_plan; edits to `db/mspbackups.rs`, `mspbackups/sync.rs`, `db/compliance.rs` (server-owned-domain sweep exclusion), `ws/mod.rs` (forgery guard), `main.rs`, `dashboard/src/components/BackupDetailTab.tsx` (per-plan).
- SPEC-027 User Management (UNCOMMITTED, branch feat/spec-027-user-management, re-review APPROVE): migration 053_user_management; new `server/src/db/user_setup_tokens.rs`, `dashboard/src/pages/Setup.tsx`; edits to `api/users.rs`, `api/auth.rs`, `auth/mod.rs`, `db/users.rs`, `api/organizations.rs`, `api/sso.rs`, `api/mod.rs`, `dashboard/src/pages/Users.tsx`, `api/client.ts`, `hooks/useAuth.tsx`, `App.tsx`, `lib/utils.ts`.

ClaudeTools (parent repo):
- NEW `.claude/skills/agy/` (SKILL.md + scripts/ask-gemini.sh) — Gemini second-opinion router (committed 2cd0c3d); image-analyze+search modes (ac0106f).
- EDIT `.claude/skills/grok/scripts/ask-grok.sh` — self-healing embed fallback for review modes (2d409a4).
- EDIT `.claude/scripts/migrate-identity.sh` — Gemini auto-detect → identity.json `gemini` block.
- NEW `.claude/memory/feedback_no_manufactured_guardrails.md` + MEMORY.md index line (this save).
- `.claude/identity.json` (local, gitignored): added `gemini` block.

Dataforth: created AD1 MSP360 `Files` backup plan (via RMM); updated `clients/dataforth/migration-gap-diff-RESUME.md` (item 1 marked DONE).

## Credentials & Secrets

- RMM test user (NEWLY CREATED): `testuser_antigravity@azcomputerguru.com` / `TestPassword123!` — role `user`, id `0b4f0b73-3ad0-4469-b885-cbbb8bede701`, argon2id hashed. Test account; rotate/delete after Antigravity testing. argon2id hash source file: `D:\tmp\agy_user_hash.txt` (local, delete when done).
- GuruRMM dashboard/API admin login used for API calls: `admin@azcomputerguru.com`, password in SOPS vault `projects/gururmm/dashboard.sops.yaml` (credentials.password). Not new.
- GuruRMM Postgres creds: SOPS `projects/gururmm/database.sops.yaml` (credentials.username=gururmm, credentials.password). Not new.
- MSP360 API creds (used to confirm Status enum): SOPS `msp-tools/msp360-api.sops.yaml`. Not new. (Carried-over: MSP360 API password leaked plaintext in older committed logs — still should be rotated.)
- Gemini CLI: Google OAuth, no API key (~/.gemini/oauth_creds.json). Nano-banana image generation would need a separate AI Studio `NANOBANANA_API_KEY` — not set up (deferred; image gen stays Grok's lane).

## Infrastructure & Servers

- `gururmm-server` (systemd unit) on 172.16.3.30:3001 (health: `http://127.0.0.1:3001/health` → OK). External API: rmm-api.azcomputerguru.com. Dashboard: rmm.azcomputerguru.com / rmm-beta.azcomputerguru.com.
- Postgres `gururmm` @ 172.16.3.30:5432 (binds 127.0.0.1; query over SSH guru@172.16.3.30, system OpenSSH). Migrations auto-apply on server restart via `sqlx::migrate!`. Latest applied this session: 052_backup_per_plan (053 pending SPEC-027 deploy).
- Deploy pipeline: push to gururmm main → webhook → server+dashboard build/deploy on 172.16.3.30; Windows AGENT build on Pluto (172.16.3.36), ~21 min, publishes to beta channel. gururmm-server restarts: VSS 14:06:32 UTC (049/050), SPEC-025 16:29:52 (051), SPEC-026 20:22:39 (052).
- Beta-channel agents: GURU-5070 (workstation, VSS OFF by default) and AD2. Stable fleet pinned 0.6.47 win / 0.6.46 linux. Post-merge agent version ~0.6.57.
- AD1: Dataforth DC, Windows Server 2016, GuruRMM agent `bf7bc5ee-4167-4a62-912a-c88b11a5943d`. AD2: Dataforth DC, Windows Server 2019, agent `cfa93bb6-0cdc-4d4e-a29e-1609cda6f047`, beta. MSP360 company "Dataforth". (Removed a stale duplicate AD2 agent record `49c66d8b-...`.)
- Gemini headless CLI: `gemini` v0.45.1 (npm global, C:\Users\guru\AppData\Roaming\npm\gemini), Google OAuth. Grok CLI: ~/.grok/bin/grok.exe v0.2.22 (OIDC).

## Commands & Outputs

- VSS on-demand snapshot (AD2): `POST /api/agents/<id>/vss/snapshots {volume:"C:"}` → shadow `{14C14867-D00F-4B2A-8866-0337515B081B}`. Scheduled task confirmed via `Get-ScheduledTask` over /rmm: `GuruRMM-VSS-Snapshot`, triggers 12:00 & 18:00 `-07:00`. owned_count 0→1 at the 12:00-AZ run.
- AD1 backup plan: `cbb.exe addBackupPlan -n "Files" -a "ACG-Dataforth" -nbf -syntheticFull yes -d "C:\Engineering" -d "C:\Shares\ITSvc" -c yes -fastNtfs yes -ntfs yes -every day -at "2:00 AM" -purge "180d" -notification errorOnly -dr yes` → "Backup plan is created." (cmd id a12d59a3). cbb.exe = `C:\Program Files\Arizona Computer Guru\Online Backup\cbb.exe`.
- RMM user create (no admin UI): argon2id hash via `py argon2-cffi`, DB insert into `users` (email,password_hash,name,role); login verified `POST /api/auth/login` → token issued.
- MSP360 Status enum confirmed from a live `/api/Monitoring` sample: 0/6=success, 1/2/5=failed, 3=running, 4=not_started, 7=partial.
- Diff-for-review trick (includes new files): `git add -A; git diff HEAD > x.diff; git reset`.

## Pending / Incomplete Tasks

- SPEC-027 User Management — re-review APPROVE, UNCOMMITTED on branch feat/spec-027-user-management. Next: pre-deploy email-dup check is DONE (no case dupes — migration 053 safe); commit (EXCLUDE stray `docs/dashboard-ux-audit-*.md`, `dashboard-redesign-*.md`, `_reconcile-draft.md`), merge to main, deploy (migration 053), validate end-to-end (create user → setup token → /setup → login → disable → immediate revocation). Post-ship LOW follow-ups: run the `#[sqlx::test]` DB suite in CI; org-level last-admin atomicity (pre-existing, non-atomic).
- Fix `ask-gemini.sh review-diff` large-payload (write diff to file, not argv) — coord/task #11.
- Stable agent rollout to bring VSS/compliance to client servers (currently only AD2/GURU-5070 on beta) — gated, deliberate.
- Unified `audit_log` (coord todo 55806c36) — consolidate per-feature audit tables.
- VSS kill-switch wiring to a server-settings table (`vss_default_behavior()` currently returns Auto).
- Rotate the leaked MSP360 API key (carried over).
- Delete `D:\tmp\agy_user_hash.txt`.
- /wiki-compile for `gururmm` (4 specs shipped) and `dataforth` (AD1 backup) — not folded in this save (root log → wiki phase skipped).

## Reference Information

- GuruRMM commits — VSS: dashboard 3bdf711, backend 700b42b, merge 29e9dbd. SPEC-025: f61e16c, merge 226ba9f. SPEC-026: dcd2b0c, merge ebe0fda. Tray fix (earlier): 137dd85.
- ClaudeTools commits — grok fallback 2d409a4, AGY skill 2cd0c3d, AGY image-analyze+search ac0106f.
- Migrations: 049_os_identity, 050_vss, 051_agent_compliance, 052_backup_per_plan (all applied); 053_user_management (pending SPEC-027 deploy).
- Specs: `projects/msp-tools/guru-rmm/docs/specs/SPEC-016/025/026/027-*.md`.
- Coord todos: unified audit_log `55806c36`; backup per-plan bug `7adaedc6` (folded into SPEC-026).
- Skills: `.claude/skills/agy/`, `.claude/skills/grok/`. Memory: `.claude/memory/feedback_no_manufactured_guardrails.md`.
- testuser_antigravity id `0b4f0b73-3ad0-4469-b885-cbbb8bede701`.

## Update: 22:06 PT — SPEC-027 User Management shipped + branch recovery

### Summary
Shipped SPEC-027 (admin user management) to production. Before committing, discovered the gururmm submodule HEAD was on `redesign/dashboard` (commit `ab3bed6`, a dashboard-redesign-docs commit from the separate `2026-06-05-rmm-dashboard-redesign-cdp` session), and that the reviewed SPEC-027 code was still uncommitted in the working tree — the redesign-docs commit had also landed on the `feat/spec-027-user-management` branch pointer. Recovered by checking out the SPEC-027 branch (carrying the uncommitted changes), `git reset --mixed origin/main` to un-commit the redesign docs (reverting them to untracked, preserved on `redesign/dashboard`), then staging only the 17 SPEC-027 files for a clean commit. Merged to main, built+deployed the server, applied migration 053, and validated the full flow live. Mike confirmed the redesign branch is intentional WIP — keeping it to finish the UI redesign first.

### Key Decisions
- Recovered SPEC-027 via `reset --mixed origin/main` rather than cherry-pick — the SPEC-027 changes were uncommitted working-tree state, so resetting the branch pointer off `ab3bed6` cleanly separated them from the redesign docs without touching the redesign branch.
- Created the validation target user with role `admin` (not `user`) so no org assignment was needed (admin roles reject org_ids) and the last-active-dev_admin disable guard did not apply.
- Bootstrapped the one required admin token by temporarily promoting the existing test account `testuser_antigravity` to `dev_admin` via a reversible DB UPDATE, logging in through the real `/auth/login`, then reverting to `user` — avoided handling any human's password or minting a JWT from the secret. Everything else ran through the live API.
- Confirmed runtime-sqlx only (no `query!`/`query_as!` macros) in the SPEC-027 files before triggering the `SQLX_OFFLINE=true` server build — no prepared cache needed; build would otherwise have failed on migration 053.

### Problems Encountered
- Submodule on wrong branch (`redesign/dashboard`) with SPEC-027 uncommitted — Gitea Agent correctly STOPPED on the precondition. Resolved with the reset-based recovery above; redesign work preserved.
- Build warned `update_user_fields`/`update_user_password`/`delete_user` "never used" — traced the PATCH/reset handlers; they call the `_tx` variants (`update_user_fields_tx`, `update_user_role_tx`, `bump_token_version_and_flag_tx`) the review required for FOR UPDATE atomicity. The non-tx helpers are dead leftovers (no security impact); flagged for deletion.
- Server deploy is NOT part of the agent webhook pipeline (that builds agents only) — server is `sudo /opt/gururmm/build-server.sh` on Saturn; ran it manually (self-contained: fetch/reset, change-gate, build, backup, deploy, restart, health-check + auto-rollback).

### Configuration Changes
- gururmm submodule: commit `8bcb024` (SPEC-027, 17 files), merge `7282020` to main; deployed SHA `3963c0c` (= merge + agent-pipeline auto-changelog commit).
- Server binary `/opt/gururmm/gururmm-server` v0.3.43 deployed; migration `053_user_management.sql` applied.
- `redesign/dashboard` branch (`ab3bed6`) preserved; redesign working-tree strays (Layout.tsx, index.css, package-lock.json, ContextTree/FunctionRail/InfrastructureSpine.tsx) left uncommitted on the feature branch for the redesign session to continue.

### Commands & Outputs
- Server build/deploy: `ssh guru@172.16.3.30 'sudo /opt/gururmm/build-server.sh'` → "Server build complete: v0.3.43" (released in 2m03s, healthy start).
- Migration check: `sudo -u postgres psql -d gururmm -tAc "SELECT version,success FROM _sqlx_migrations WHERE version=53;"` → `53|t`.
- Live validation harness (curl against http://172.16.3.30:3001/api): create→201, setup redeem→200, target login→200, pre-disable /auth/me→200, disable→200, post-disable /auth/me→403 (revoked), re-redeem setup token→400 (single-use). Cleanup: target deleted (204), testuser reverted to `user`, 0 orphan setup tokens.

### Pending / Incomplete Tasks (delta)
- SPEC-027 DONE (shipped + validated). Remaining LOW: run `#[sqlx::test]` DB suite in CI; org-level last-admin atomicity (pre-existing); delete the 3 dead non-tx user DB helpers.
- Task #15: finish UI redesign on `redesign/dashboard` (ab3bed6), then merge to main. Mike: redesign first.
- Still open: ask-gemini.sh review-diff large-payload (#11); VSS kill-switch wiring; stable agent rollout (VSS/compliance to client servers); unified audit_log (55806c36); rotate leaked MSP360 key; delete D:\tmp\agy_user_hash.txt.

### Reference
- Commits: SPEC-027 `8bcb024`, merge `7282020`, deployed `3963c0c`. Server v0.3.43. Migration 053 applied.
- Validation actor: testuser_antigravity (id 0b4f0b73-3ad0-4469-b885-cbbb8bede701), promoted/reverted dev_admin↔user.
- Coord: component gururmm/server → deployed v0.3.43.
