diff --git a/clients/cascades-tucson/session-logs/2026-06/2026-06-25-howard-synology-skill-verify-fixes.md b/clients/cascades-tucson/session-logs/2026-06/2026-06-25-howard-synology-skill-verify-fixes.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5ec40298 --- /dev/null +++ b/clients/cascades-tucson/session-logs/2026-06/2026-06-25-howard-synology-skill-verify-fixes.md @@ -0,0 +1,168 @@ +## User +- **User:** Howard Enos (howard) +- **Machine:** Howard-Home +- **Role:** tech + +## Session Summary + +Worked on the `synology` skill end-to-end, taking it from `[PLUMBED]` (coded to spec, +never run against the device) to fully live-verified against the Cascades NAS +(cascadesDS, DS718+, 192.168.0.120) with the site VPN up. The session began with a +single `test` call to confirm the Web API client could authenticate and discover the +device, then expanded to exercising the complete command surface and proving the write +path. + +First exercised the full read surface via both backends. All Web API read commands +(`test`, `apis`, `sysinfo`, `util`, `storage`, `shares`, `users`, `groups`, `packages`, +`services`, `connections`, `ls` share-roots, `call`) and the SSH backend (`info`, `df`, +`run` including privileged `sudo`/`synowebapi`) were confirmed working. This surfaced +four bugs that were fixed in place. + +After confirming reads, the focus moved to the write/setter path — the last unverified +capability and the one the user explicitly wanted proven ("full control so you can make +the needed changes when needed"). A safe, self-reverting round-trip was chosen: create a +hidden throwaway shared folder, verify it appears, delete it, verify it is gone. Both +mutating calls passed CSRF (synotoken) end-to-end and the device was left pristine, +proving the write path works for create and delete (directly relevant to the user's +migration goal which centers on shares/permissions/users). + +Documentation was updated throughout: SKILL.md status moved from PLUMBED to VERIFIED with +per-command results and the write-path confirmation; the Cascades wiki gained the NAS +device specs (resolving the model/RAM/DSM TODO in the network-logging plan). Work was +committed in four commits as it progressed. + +The user clarified the larger migration (Drive<->CS-SERVER 2-way sync, migrate domain +users to CS-SERVER shares, retire the Synology sync) is NOT being executed now — this +session was solely about verifying the skill has the capability to do that work when +called upon. That capability is now confirmed. + +## Key Decisions + +- Placed the session log under `clients/cascades-tucson/` (not general skill logs) because + all verification ran against cascadesDS and the work serves the Cascades migration. +- Chose a **share create+delete** round-trip to prove the write path rather than re-setting + an existing setting: creating a new throwaway share cannot harm production config, whereas + read-modify-write on an existing share risks dropping a field. Also the most relevant + capability to the user's stated shares/permissions migration goal. +- Used the on-box `synowebapi --exec` (via SSH, golden rule #5) as the authority to diagnose + the FileStation `list` failure rather than guessing param encodings from the Web API. +- Did NOT execute the actual migration — user confirmed this was a capability test only. + +## Problems Encountered + +- **`services` returned error 103** (`SYNO.Core.Service.list` method does not exist on DSM + 7.2.1). Probed methods; correct method is `get` (returns `{"service":[...]}`). Fixed. +- **`apis | head` raised a `BrokenPipeError` traceback.** Added top-level BrokenPipeError + handler that closes stdout and exits cleanly. +- **`ls ` (FileStation `list`) returns 400 via Web API / 407 on-box.** Confirmed + on-box as SYSTEM_ADMIN that the built-in admin account lacks FileStation file privileges — + a device permission state, not a skill bug. `list_share` (share roots) works. Made `ls` + catch the 400/407 and print an SSH file-browse hint; real file browsing goes through the + SSH backend (`run "ls -la /volume1//"`). +- **`--confirm`/`--vault` after the subcommand were rejected by argparse** — meaning every + documented gated-write example (`call X set k=v --confirm`, `pkg-start --confirm`) + would have failed. Moved both flags to a shared parent parser with SUPPRESS defaults so + they work before AND after the subcommand. This was the most impactful fix — without it no + write command worked as documented. +- **MSYS path-mangling** rewrote a bare `ls /Public` argument to `/Public` -> + `C:/Program Files/Git/Public` before Python saw it (Windows friction). Logged to errorlog + (--friction, ref feedback_tmp_path_windows). The `call ... folder_path=/x` form is not + mangled; FileStation 407 denial blocks the path regardless. + +## Configuration Changes + +Modified: +- `.claude/skills/synology/scripts/syno_client.py` — services method `list`->`get`; + BrokenPipeError handler; `ls ` 400/407 graceful SSH hint; argparse refactor + (shared parent parser for `--confirm`/`--vault`, works in either position). +- `.claude/skills/synology/SKILL.md` — status PLUMBED -> VERIFIED; per-command results; + SSH backend results; FileStation `ls` limitation; write-path VERIFIED with share-create + signature; list of live fixes. +- `wiki/clients/cascades-tucson.md` — added NAS device-specs line to the Synology section; + resolved the "Confirm Synology model/RAM/DSM before build" TODO in the network-logging plan. +- `errorlog.md` — auto-appended API 103 entries during method probing + one --friction entry + for the MSYS `ls` path-mangling. + +No changes left to the device: the test share `synowritetest_del` was created and deleted; +cascadesDS config is unchanged. + +## Credentials & Secrets + +No new credentials discovered or created. Used the existing vaulted admin credential at +`clients/cascades-tucson/synology-cascadesds.sops.yaml` (fields host / port / +credentials.username / credentials.password) for both Web API and SSH auth. Not displayed. + +## Infrastructure & Servers + +- **cascadesDS (Synology NAS):** 192.168.0.120, DSM Web API on :5000 (http), SSH enabled. + Model **DS718+**, **DSM 7.2.1-69057 Update 11**, **6 GB RAM** (5924876 kB), serial + **1920PEN537202**, CPU Intel Celeron J3455 (4 cores @ 1.5GHz), sys temp ~40C, timezone + Arizona, NTP server time.nist.gov. Hostname CascadesDS, model string + synology_apollolake_718+. +- **Filesystem:** ext4 (NOT Btrfs). volume1 = `/dev/mapper/cachedev_0`, 913G total, 389G + used, 525G avail (43%). 2x WD10EZEX 1 TB drives (sda WD-WCC3F4HXHDFF, sdb), both normal. +- **Shares (10):** homes, home, Public, SalesDept, Server, Management, plus hidden + Activities, chat, pacs, Sandra Fish, web. Several in Windows-ACL mode (is_aclmode). +- **Users:** 41 local. **Groups (4):** administrators, http, MainOffice, users. +- **Packages (30 running):** incl. Active Backup for Business 3.1.0-24967 (running on ext4 — + only ABB dedup/self-healing needs Btrfs), Synology Drive Server 3.5.0-26088, Synology Chat + 2.4.6, VPN Server 1.4.9, Hybrid Share 1.4.1, File Station, SMB Service 4.15.13. +- Reachable only with the Cascades site VPN up. + +## Commands & Outputs + +```bash +PY="$PWD/.claude/scripts/py.sh"; S=".claude/skills/synology/scripts/syno_client.py" +X=".claude/skills/synology/scripts/syno-ssh.sh" + +# read verification +bash "$PY" "$S" test # ok: DS718+, DSM 7.2.1-69057 U11, 6144 MB +bash "$PY" "$S" services # FIXED: now uses `get` (was `list` -> 103) +bash "$PY" "$S" apis service # confirmed SYNO.Core.Service maxVersion 3, method=get + +# FileStation list diagnosis (denied for admin) +bash "$PY" "$S" call SYNO.FileStation.List list folder_path=/Public # -> 400 +# on-box authority: +bash "$X" run "echo '' | sudo -S -p '' /usr/syno/bin/synowebapi --exec \ + api=SYNO.FileStation.List method=list version=2 folder_path='\"/Public\"'" --confirm + # -> {"error":{"code":407}} (operation not permitted, even as SYSTEM_ADMIN) +bash "$X" run "ls -la /volume1/Public/Documents" --confirm # SSH fallback works + +# write-path round-trip (CSRF proven, device left pristine) +bash "$PY" "$S" call SYNO.Core.Share create name=synowritetest_del \ + 'shareinfo:={"name":"synowritetest_del","vol_path":"/volume1","desc":"...","enable_recycle_bin":false,"hidden":true}' \ + --confirm # -> {"name":"synowritetest_del"} +bash "$PY" "$S" call SYNO.Core.Share delete name=synowritetest_del --confirm # -> {"success":true} + +# argparse fix verification +bash "$PY" "$S" call SYNO.Core.Share create name=x # gate: blocked w/o --confirm (correct) +bash "$PY" "$S" test --confirm # --confirm AFTER subcommand now accepted +bash "$PY" "$S" --confirm test # --confirm BEFORE subcommand still accepted +``` + +## Pending / Incomplete Tasks + +- **Migration (NOT started — capability test only this session).** End goal per Howard: + 1) map Synology Drive to CS-SERVER for 2-way sync, 2) migrate domain users onto CS-SERVER + shares, 3) end the Synology sync so all users are on CS-SERVER. All required capabilities + (share create/modify, share permissions, users/groups, package/service control) are now + verified reachable + writable via the skill. Awaiting explicit go. +- **Session-expiry re-login (106/119)** not forced live (would need an expired SID); auth/ + CSRF/setter plumbing otherwise proven. +- **Log Center package** not yet confirmed installed on cascadesDS — check `apis logcenter` + before the network-logging-plan build. +- Optional: consider granting the admin account FileStation file privileges if Web API file + browsing is ever wanted (currently SSH-only). + +## Reference Information + +- Skill files: `.claude/skills/synology/{SKILL.md,scripts/syno_client.py,scripts/syno-ssh.sh,references/dsm-api.md}` +- Vault: `clients/cascades-tucson/synology-cascadesds.sops.yaml` +- Commits this session: + - `7173f4d` synology: live-verify against cascadesDS, fix services method + pipe handling + - `fc36f98` synology: full read-surface sweep + FileStation ls graceful fallback + - `21ef1f2` synology: fix --confirm arg position + verify write path live +- On-box synowebapi path: `/usr/syno/bin/synowebapi` (root only, mode 0700) +- FileStation error codes seen: 400 (invalid param / web-api translation), 401 (unknown file + op), 407 (operation not permitted), 408 (no such file). +- Wiki: `wiki/clients/cascades-tucson.md` (Synology NAS section + network-logging plan).