claudetools/clients/cascades-tucson/docs/security/hipaa.md

HIPAA Compliance — Cascades

Why HIPAA Applies

Cascades is an assisted living facility with health services staff (nurses, medtechs, health services director). They handle Protected Health Information (PHI) through:

1. ALIS (https://www.go-alis.com/) — cloud-hosted clinical/medical records system, accessed via web browser on staff PCs
2. Synology NAS (cascadesDS) — stores resident/facility data locally that falls under HIPAA
3. CS-SERVER file shares — migration target for Synology data; will become the primary secured storage
4. M365 email — staff may send/receive resident-related information via cascadestucson.com email

Project Mission

Cascades was taken over from a previous MSP that left the environment insecure and non-compliant. The core objective of the migration project is to get Cascades secure and HIPAA compliant. Every migration phase ties back to this goal.

Current HIPAA Gaps

#	Gap	Severity	HIPAA Rule	Migration Phase
1	No backup exists	Critical	§164.308(a)(7) — Contingency Plan	Phase 0 (WSB → Synology) + Phase 4 (offsite)
2	Synology stores PHI with no access auditing	Critical	§164.312(b) — Audit Controls	Phase 4 (move to CS-SERVER with NTFS audit)
3	Shared accounts (Receptionist, Culinary, saleshare, directoryshare)	High	§164.312(a)(2)(i) — Unique User ID	Phase 5 (replace with individual accounts)
4	No MFA on M365	High	§164.312(d) — Person Authentication	Can enable now (Security Defaults, free)
5	No disk encryption (BitLocker)	High	§164.312(a)(2)(iv) — Encryption	Phase 2.6 GPO (free with Windows Pro)
6	Permissive floating firewall rule	High	§164.312(e)(1) — Transmission Security	Phase 1.6 (post-migration lockdown)
7	Non-IT staff in Domain Admins	High	§164.312(a)(1) — Access Control	Phase 2.2 (remove Meredith.Kuhn, John.Trozzi)
8	Most PCs not domain-joined	Medium	§164.308(a)(3) — Workforce Security	Phase 3 (domain join all staff PCs)
9	No GPOs enforced (password policy, screen lock)	Medium	§164.308(a)(5) — Security Awareness	Phase 2.6 (Security Baseline GPO)
10	Kitchen iPads on same VLAN as staff PCs	Medium	§164.312(e)(1) — Transmission Security	Restrict iPads to kitchen printers only
11	ALIS browser access on shared PCs	Medium	§164.312(d) — Person Authentication	Phase 5 (individual logins, no shared accounts)
12	No BAA verified with ALIS	Medium	§164.308(b)(1) — Business Associates	Verify with management
13	No BAA with Microsoft (M365)	Medium	§164.308(b)(1) — Business Associates	Sign Microsoft BAA via M365 admin
14	Sandra Fish still global admin	Low	§164.308(a)(3) — Workforce Security	Create break-glass admin, remove Sandra
15	No M365 backup	Low	§164.308(a)(7) — Contingency Plan	Future — Veeam Backup for M365

How Migration Phases Address HIPAA

Phase	What It Does	HIPAA Controls Addressed
Phase 0 — Safety Net	Windows Server Backup → Synology SMB share	Backup, contingency plan
Phase 1 — Network	VLAN migration, firewall lockdown, guest isolation	Transmission security, access control
Phase 2 — Server Prep	AD cleanup, security groups, GPOs (BitLocker, passwords, screen lock)	Access control, audit, encryption, unique user ID
Phase 3 — Domain Join	All staff PCs under centralized management	Workforce security, device management
Phase 4 — Synology Retirement	Move data to CS-SERVER with NTFS permissions + audit logging	Audit controls, access control, integrity
Phase 5 — Hardening	Remove shared accounts, RDS cleanup, final lockdown	Unique user ID, person authentication

Systems and PHI Flow

Nurses/MedTechs (staff PCs)
    │
    ├──► ALIS (cloud, go-alis.com) — clinical/medical records
    │        └── ALIS responsible for their own HIPAA compliance + BAA
    │
    ├──► Synology NAS (cascadesDS, 192.168.0.120) — resident/facility data (MOVING TO CS-SERVER)
    │
    ├──► CS-SERVER (192.168.2.254) — file shares, AD, DNS (migration target)
    │
    └──► M365 (cascadestucson.com) — email, may contain PHI in messages/attachments

Non-PHI Systems (out of HIPAA scope)

System	Purpose	Notes
Kitchen iPads (9 units)	Food order taking	No PHI — only need access to kitchen thermal receipt printers. Managed via ManageEngine MDM
Kitchen thermal printers	Receipt printing	Bistro (TM-T88VII, 192.168.2.207) + Kitchen (TM-U220IIB, 10.0.20.225)
Resident room VLANs	Resident personal devices (TVs, phones)	No PHI — isolated /28 per room
Ring cameras (8 units)	Security cameras	No PHI
GoDaddy	Website hosting (cascadestucson.com)	Public website, no PHI

New Findings from Audit (2026-03-20)

#	Gap	Severity	HIPAA Rule	Notes
16	3 shared accounts with no password (Nurses, memfrtdesk, Front Desk) — these PCs access ALIS	Critical	§164.312(a)(2)(i) — Unique User ID	NURSESTATION-PC, MEMRECEPT-PC, RECEPTIONIST-PC
17	No audit logging on CS-SERVER (Object Access = No Auditing)	Critical	§164.312(b) — Audit Controls	Cannot track who accessed PHI files
18	13 months without Windows updates on DESKTOP-LPOPV30	High	§164.308(a)(1) — Security Management	6 machines 3+ months behind
19	Expired SSL certificate on CS-SERVER (2025-04-02)	High	§164.312(e)(1) — Transmission Security	Causes Schannel errors
20	krbtgt password 569 days old	High	§164.312(a)(1) — Access Control	Should rotate every 180 days
21	RDP without NLA on ASSISTMAN-PC, DESKTOP-U2DHAP0	High	§164.312(e)(1) — Transmission Security	Credential exposure risk
22	TightVNC on MEMRECEPT-PC	High	§164.312(a)(1) — Access Control	Unauthorized remote access tool
23	No LAPS — same local admin password on all machines	Medium	§164.312(a)(1) — Access Control	Lateral movement risk
24	RestrictAnonymous = 0 on CS-SERVER	Medium	§164.312(a)(1) — Access Control	Null sessions allowed
25	Protected Users group empty	Medium	§164.312(a)(1) — Access Control	Admin accounts not protected
26	Share permissions: Everyone=FullControl on multiple shares	Medium	§164.312(a)(1) — Access Control	Culinary, directoryshare, Roaming

Quick Wins (Free, Can Do Now)

1. Enable MFA on M365 — Security Defaults in Entra ID (free, takes 5 minutes)
2. Sign Microsoft BAA — M365 Admin Center → Settings → Org Settings → Security & Privacy → HIPAA BAA
3. Verify ALIS BAA — Ask management if they have a signed BAA with go-alis.com
4. BitLocker GPO — Enable via Security Baseline GPO once PCs are domain-joined (Phase 2.6)

Recommendations (Paid)

Service	Why	Cost	Priority
Veeam Backup for M365	Protect email/OneDrive containing PHI	~$2-4/user/mo	Medium
Business Premium upgrade	DLP (prevent PHI in outbound email), Defender, Conditional Access	+$10/user/mo (~$340/mo net after shared mailbox savings)	Low — most gaps covered by free controls

Notes

• Cascades is assisted living, not a hospital — but nurses and medtechs handle PHI, making HIPAA applicable
• Previous MSP left the environment non-compliant — this project is a remediation effort
• ALIS handles the heavy clinical data in the cloud — local HIPAA focus is on access control, backup, encryption, and audit trails
• Kitchen area (iPads, thermal printers) is out of HIPAA scope — food service only